Justin Herbert keeps putting up numbers that would make most quarterbacks headline every major sports show — yet somehow, he still isn’t talked about like he’s elite. Whether it’s injuries, inconsistent coaching, or simply being overshadowed by flashier storylines, Herbert never seems to get the flowers he deserves. But anyone watching the tape knows the truth: this dude is different.
The Numbers Don’t Lie
Herbert’s efficiency is outrageous for someone critics claim isn’t a “top guy.” He consistently ranks high in:
-
yards per attempt
-
completion percentage
-
big-time throws under pressure
-
low turnover-worthy plays
These aren’t empty stats — they reflect decision-making, accuracy, and situational mastery. When a quarterback can push the ball downfield AND take care of it, he’s special.
The Eye Test
Numbers can tell you what’s happening. The film tells you why. Herbert makes throws most QBs won’t even attempt — laser beams into tight windows, cross-field touch balls, back-foot completions under pressure. His arm talent is elite, but what’s even more impressive is how calm he stays when everything breaks down around him.
He’s Doing More With Less
Herbert hasn’t always had the best help:
-
Injured WRs
-
Rotating coordinators
-
Questionable late-game coaching
-
Defensive collapses
A lot of quarterbacks look good when everything’s stable. Herbert looks good even when everything’s burning around him. That’s the difference.
Can He Win Big?
The biggest criticism is that Herbert hasn’t won enough. Fair — quarterback legacy is tied to winning. But football is the ultimate team sport. You don’t win because your QB is good — you win because everything works. The Chargers have yet to give him a complete roster and coaching staff. When they do? Look out.
The Bottom Line
Herbert might not get the prime-time attention other quarterbacks do, but ask defensive coordinators which QB they fear — he’s top three every time. Numbers, film, decision-making, poise — it’s all there. He’s elite. He’s special. He’s underrated. The league knows it… even if the headlines don’t. And if people keep sleeping? That’s fine — charge it to the game.
